Kevin Rose in Concert – Encore Musical Theatre (review)

Every now and then, a rising star swings through the Ann Arbor area, most recently thanks to Dexter’s Encore Musical Theatre Company, and treats the audience to an evening of polished, superb Broadway fare that really makes you think about the amazing talent out there in the world, and how fortunate we are in the area to have them drop by.

Kevin Rose

New York City-based Kevin Rose (recently appearing in Plaid Tidings, and now the title role in Joseph…Dreamcoat) took a night off from his normal musical theater duties to present a sublime evening of (mostly) love songs from Broadway, off-Broadway, and even a little Beatles sprinkled in. Supported by the ever-charismatic Sebastian Gerstner and pitch-perfect Thalia Schramm, clear-voiced Rose sang through delightful songs from She Loves Me, West Side Story, Into the Woods, Carousel, and some lesser known shows like I Love You Your Perfect Now Change, I Love You Because, and (ever workshopping) Elyria. Accompaniment was provided by R MacKenzie Lewis and his three-piece ensemble.

Rose’s voice is particularly lush in ballads like “If I Loved You”, and “My Funny Valentine”…but he also has a delightful mischievous side that had the audience rocking with laughter often throughout the 80 minute set.  His musical choices are good, and the entire evening very well rehearsed and energized. Its a concert cabaret performance he can take with him anywhere, and I hope he does. Rose joins an ever-growing number of performers like Laura Osnes and Erich Bergen who can ply their wares nationwide, and share the enthusiasm of musical theater wherever they are through their cabaret performances. Meanwhile, you can catch Kevin in Joseph through March 3rd at the Encore.

SMASH is back, and its as infuriating as ever…

Reviewed after screening the first three hours of the new season (NBC has telecast to the first two hours this week).

Well, Smash is back on NBC, and your like (or dislike) of the show will directly relate to a) your ability to tolerate Katharine McPhee, b) your enjoyment of musical theater as a whole, and c) your like/dislike of soap opera.

Here’s the good news — they’ve toned down the ridiculous interpersonal stories for Messing and her husband (even if it does mean we don’t get to see the excellent Brian D’Arcy James anymore this season) and sent their whining son off to boarding school. They’ve also gotten rid of the horrendous scheming plotline for Ellis (goodbye) and enigma Dev (goodbye).

The many Broadway actors that appear in the show, in cameos, in songs, in backgrounds continues to astound — witness Brynn O’Malley’s excellent little scene firing Jack Davenport. Fun, fierce, and Facebook-worthy.

They’ve also brought on the excellent Jennifer Hudson and Jeremy Jordan, and UM’s Andy Mientus to round out a new storyline. In the first three hours, the show absolutely comes to life when Hudson or Jordan sing — and crashes when the old McPhee/Hilty story comes into view.

And the show actually follows the development of a musical more this season, rather than the soap-opera-like antics of supporting characters. How will the money for the production be raised. How will media rumors hinder the development of “Bombshell”, the Marilyn musical (note to producers: Marilyn Monroe is not interesting, and the musical version already bombed on Broadway), and how will distractions of lawsuits and sexual harassment play into the development of the show.

Pasek and Paul (another feel-good UM success story!) provide some new songs that are a notch above the “everything in Bombshell sounds like it was cut from Hairspray” music of last season.

But that is where the good news ends. The show still depends on time-worn cliches more relevant to soap opera than to musical theater, and a lack of reality that is astonishing…that any single producer or artistic staff of any show anywhere would cast the lackluster McPhee in a lead role over the superb Megan Hilty is just television storytelling of the worst kind. The entire storyline rings false from top to bottom. And when you bring in a rising star like Jordan, why saddle it all down with a ridiculous badboy drug-addict subplot…and throw superstar Hudson into another mother (Dreamgirl Sheryl Lee ralph)/daughter conflict subplot. BLECH.

The musical numbers continue to be the shows highpoint — and they are better integrated into the plotline this season; but the ongoing use of near-public-domain pop songs rather than theater songs is disappointing and panders to the American Idol and Glee set.

I say put Bernadette Peters and Sheryl Lee Ralph into a room and let them duke it out.

Don’t get me wrong, I love to see my Broadway folks at work…but I am not a fan of Smash, even though I watch it just to see what jawdropping disaster befalls the cast each week — like watching a train wreck, and enjoying it for what it is. Still, the show is a notch above most primetime soap-opera fare. But that is where it stands. Its not a comedy. Its not a drama. Its a bizarre mix of soap opera and musical theater. And that’s the view from here.

ANYTHING GOES and WICKED in San Francisco (Tour update)

While in San Francisco this past week, I had the opportunity to catch up with two favorite Broadway shows on tour — the first national tours of ANYTHING GOES and WICKED. Good news for the former, not so much for the latter.

Anything Goes (which I originally saw in NYC and then on tour in East Lansing) continues to get tighter as it goes. The entire cast is stronger than the original Broadway cast, and Rachel York is simply superb as Reno Sweeney. Erich Bergen is as smooth as a glass of scotch playing Billy Crocker (catch his cabaret act in whatever town the show is currently playing!). Fred Applegate continues to amaze as Moonface Martin. Alex Finke is lovable as Hope, and Chuck Wagner steady as the Captain. Edward Staudenmayer’s performance as Sir Evelyn has grown and grown, and he is a wonder, especially once the show plunges headlong into “The Gypsy in Me” sequence in Act Two. Overall, the Anything Goes tour is one of the strongest casts you are going to see in this very strong production. Do not hesitate to get tickets.

WICKED, on the other hand, is showing its age. While most of the performances in the current first national tour are first rate, some of the cast members have far outlived their roles. Dee Roscioli continues to play a fine Elphaba, but her counterpart Patti Murin as Glinda is starting to look tired. Cliffton Hall sings a fine Fiyero, but is getting too old to play the part. He’s been doing this for a long time, and where he used to look boyish, he now looks like a man…a 40-year old man (he’s 39). Justin Brill (35) is particularly too old to be playing Boq at this point. 

The cyclorama is water damaged and wrinkled, and it is particularly startling to see this in a Broadway set. When hit with amber or orange light, the wrinkles show from center stage left all the way to upper stage left. You can tell someone has taken the time to try to straighten things out — because the handprints show in large streaks along the edges of the clockface on the cyc. Its unforgivable. Fortunately, the First National tour is still using the fully realized sets, including the bridge, which the other tour companies have now downsized to flats. 

Its a mixed bag overall — but Wicked is in need of some fresh cast members, and some cleaning up and tightening as it continues its journey on its eternal tour. 

2012 Musical Theater Season in SE Michigan – The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly…

It’s hard to make a “best of” list in this area of the country, since the blend of collegiate, community, and professional often overlap and sometimes Community theater productions can be as good as (or better) than some professional productions, while at other times, college shows can look better than Broadway tours….nonetheless, here is my summary of the good, the bad, and the ugly…

The Best overall community theater production this past year was: GREY GARDENS at Ann Arbor Civic Theater. Special kudos to Kathy Waugh for her terrific performance.

The Best summer theater production was: SEVEN BRIDES FOR SEVEN BROTHERS at Croswell Opera House. Its been a long long time since Croswell had such a dance-tacular production, thanks to the Hissong’s direction and choreography.

The Best summer theater production that was indistinguishable from a Broadway Tour: AVENUE Q at Croswell Opera House. It was so good, it was hard to even compare it to other local productions, it had to be held to professional Broadway tour standards — and it was as good as, if not better, than the tour that came through Michigan a few years ago.

Speaking of tours: The best Broadway Tour to come through Detroit was: JEKYLL & HYDE — Broadway Bound with a spectacular Tobin Ost set, and a remarkable performance by Constantine Maroulis.

The best Broadway Tour to come through Wharton Center in East Lansing was: ANYTHING GOES, with a touring cast led by Rachel York that was stronger than the Original Broadway cast.

The best local university musical was: CHICAGO at the University of Michigan. Although it had strong runners-up in SUNDAY IN THE PARK WITH GEORGE (also at UM) and LEGALLY BLONDE at MSU. Also delicious was SWEENEY TODD at Sienna Heights.

Speaking of Legally Blonde: I saw 4 productions of this show, and despite varied levels of good lead performances, it just goes to show that this is a musical that is hard to recreate without a multi-million dollar budget. The Original Broadway production is so deeply visually ingrained (thanks to MTV’s relentless showings a few years ago) that any non-professional production just pales in comparison. One favorite note: in the Croswell production, when the trailer door stuck, David Blackburn hilariously announced “I’ll just use the back door!” and came around from stage left complete with bulldog. It was the biggest laugh of any show I saw this past year.

The best small-cast show of the year: THE LAST 5 YEARS at Jackson Symphony Space — Jayna Katz and Adam Woolsey blew the roof off of the place nightly.

The best “becoming an annual tradition around here” musical: EVIL DEAD THE MUSICAL at Dexter Community Players. Expanding community theater’s boundaries by squirts and bounds, with a strong cast and twice the splatter-power.

I wasn’t impressed much by any of the local professional musical theater productions this year, although there were some mighty fine performances. The Dionysus Theater made a strong debut as a professional theater company with their holiday offering HOME FOR THE HOLIDAYS – right out of the gate hitting all the right notes in a finely performed production in a gorgeous proscenium theater space.  A couple shows will go without mention here, because I abhor when major changes are made to Broadway musicals to fit a director’s “vision” or a small budget — but it is worthy to mention the lovely GODSPELL at Encore, where Dan Cooney took a show that has become bloated and almost unwatchable over the years, and turned it into a fresh, sparse, and clown-makeup-free delight.

Finally — one “ugly” — the reworked BEAUTY AND THE BEAST arrived at the Stranahan on tour, with a non-equity NETworks production, featuring some of the ugliest costumes and sets I have seen in a Broadway tour. UGH.

 

 

Funniest TV Quotes 2012

Here it is — my favorite/funniest quotes list of the best of TV 2012 — of course, I haven’t seen every show, but of those I have, here’s the annual list!  Enjoy —

“Do you smell that? Fresh cut grass.”

“Well, if its fresh cut its not ours.” — The Middle

“I prepared the clams in the traditional way, and then sampled them, and disposed of them. You can thank me very much.” – Happy Endings

Emma: “Got anything in that bag that can help me with a beanstalk?”

Mulan: “A hook.”

Cpt Hook: “Hey!” — Once Upon a Time

“Pastel walls give me the chills” – The New Girl

“So Mike and Rusty made up, which wasn’t too hard since Rusty didn’t even realize they were in a fight” — The Middle

“I don’t know what you two are up to. I think its amazing. I want no part of it.” — Happy Endings

“This place is so unappealing even I don’t look good here” — 2 Broke Girls

“For heavens sake, change out of those wingtips, your a kid…your not Nixon on the beach” – Modern Family

“You have to outsing Anna!…Do you know “Send in the Clowns?” cause I could help you” — Ben and Kate

“Our community has not yet learned how to modulate baby gifts” — Modern Family

“Robin and Patrice’s BFF Fun Day!” — HIMYM

“Do not fall into the evidence, Hodgins….it will only add to the humiliation” — Bones

“You can’t ask Wil Wheaton to leave…he’s a minor celebrity….once you explain who he is people recognize him” — The Big Bang Theory

“We’ve been laughing all night! (long pause). Except for right now, now its just weird” – Suburgatory

“Haley, this is real life, not an excellent movie” – Modern Family

‎”The thing I learned from ‘Hoarders’ is that it usually doesn’t end well for the cats” — The Middle

“I figured the best way to talk to Models was just to point to things and label them — this table is round and flat” — The New Girl

“That girl is so whack, her first name should be Knick-Knack-Patty” — Happy Endings

“Neither you, nor Cleveland, knows how to get over someone leaving you” – HIMYM

“Oh Damnit, I forgot to punish Brick”

“He didn’t lick another mailbox, did he?” — The Middle

Becket: “Take your hand off your tool, Marco”

Castle: (snickers)

Becket: “Shut up” — Castle

“A suicidal lemur has got my gun” — American Dad

“Was it great? No…was it good?….no” — Partners

“Twitter is stupid, and Instagram is Twitter for people who can’t read” — 2 Broke Girls

“Why was this more fun when we were kids?”

“Because when we were kids we didn’t have kids” – The Middle

“See, this is why my people spank” — The New Normal

“I don’t know, I’ve always been a bit of a saboteur” — Happy Endings

“Cleanings not her thing, but she has other strengths”

“Em, I don’t see them” — Two Broke Girls

“I am so tired of people using ‘Vanilla Sky’ to defend everything.” — Happy Endings

“I’m not completely secure when I sneeze” –Patsy, AbFab Olympics Special

“No one is going to judge me on my past. Everyone is going to judge me on my cheerleading talent alone.”

“She keeps saying that like its a good thing” — The Middle

“I won’t change too much — I’ll be like the old me, only a little bit different….like a Coldplay album” — Not Going Out

“That sounds like quite an embroglio”…Cougar Town

“If we don’t find that tutu, we’ll have to cut Clara, which will make us look ridiculous” — Bunheads

“Oh, how very Turning Point” — Bunheads

“That rude Roo ruined my room” — Suburgatory

“I’m only an okay storm, I’m not a perfect storm” — Cougar Town

“You are clearly having thoughts….you should go see the Guidance Counselor” — The Middle

‎”Want to see some real zombies, check out the red carpet at the Tony Awards” — Castle

“I don’t miss the sex…I miss summer in Minsk….I miss smoking in hospitals.” — Two Broke Girls

” I didn’t roll my eyes…I just had to really quickly look at the ceiling” –The New Girl

“Are you a Bond villain? Cause you just told me your whole plan”…The New Girl

“I was gonna help you, but then I didn’t want to”….Don’t Trust the B in Apt 23

“When I get married, I hope I’m just as pregnant as you”…Cougar Town

“How many times have I said I want to do beading?”

“I don’t know…never?” — The Middle

“These shorts are for a younger person, wouldn’t you say?” — Sprint Commercial

“I’m KFC, baby….you don’t mess with the Colonel’s recipe….”  — Barney, HIMYM

“Do you know what the worst part of today was?”

“I imagine it’s hard to choose….” — Modern Family

“There’s no availability at the Inn…” – Bones

“Ive never said you are not good at what you do….it’s just that what you do isn’t worth doing….” – Big bang Theory

“I broke my leg while ski-boxing….it’s a sport created by energy drinks” — Happy Endings

“I knew our group would get weird….now I know what it was like to be in ‘No Doubt'” — Whitney

“Usually my hook is that its closing time and I’m there”….The New GIrl

‘OMG, I have been doing this a long time and I have never seen a credit score that low…did you just

wake up from a coma?”….The New Girl

“Dahlia, you can’t just throw Hangover Monkeys at the problem.” — Suburgatory

“Those people were victims of a Fonzie scheme” – Modern Family

“I have tons of wallet chains you can borrow” — Schmidt, The New Girl

“People are talking…okay, it’s mostly us…and that’s usually how it starts…” — Suburgatory

“I love you….I blew up a Chipotle for you!” — 2 Broke Girls

“I do things….I read half a book about Zombies…”  – Nick, The New GIrl

“Can I offer you a Swedish Massage….accent optional?”…Phil, Modern Family

“This is a horrible neighborhood…there are youths everywhere.”

“Youths???…Who are you, Officer Krupke?” — The New Girl

“I don’t think its fair for me to be on a jury, because I am a hologram” — 30Rock

“Now she’s cavorting with dwarves? When did THAT happen?” – Evil Queen, Once Upon a Time

“Oh my God, I’ve been using an old hooker’s lipgloss” — Two Broke Girls

“Damn it, I can’t find my driving moccasins anywhere” — Schmidt, The New Girl

“Its my fault the dog fell in the pool…I let her out but then got caught up in my couponing” – Manny, Modern Family

“Do you know what’s under that hockey jersey?”

“A Family Guy tattoo?” — Happy Endings

“Live long and suck it, Zachary Quinto” – The Big Bang Theory

“Les Miserables” movie is stunning, emotional, and divisive (Review)

Do you hear the people sing? Do you scour all the movie reviews to decide if you want to see a movie or not? Do you trust your Facebook friends and their opinions? It seems everyone has an opinion on “Les Miserables”, the movie adaptation of the long-running stage musical. I, among many, just loved it.

Image

Arriving nearly intact from its stage incarnation, its a good adaptation of the musical, and almost every change made is helpful.  A few of the songs have been re-ordered to give them more flow in a movie setting, and a few lyrics have been changed, along with two all-new recitatives that catapult several short scenes into one There is also one new song, “Suddenly”, added for your consideration, Academy (since songs from another medium are not eligible).

Hugh Jackman is a convincing Jean Valjean, and delivers the money songs at full voice. There’s little subtlety in his performance, but it fits the style of this production. Sure, Alfie Boe would have sung a far superior “Bring Him Home”, but Alfie Boe would not have sold 18.5 million dollars worth of tickets in the first day. Russell Crowe, much maligned as Inspector Javert, actually turns in a very decent performance — having seen the stage production in London, NYC, and various tours probably more than a dozen times, I can easily say that he is no worse than some stage Javerts, while a far cry from the best of them. His singing voice is somewhat lackluster: its not off key, it’s not horrible, but it lacks inflection. While lack of inflection seems to be a necessity in rock bands these days (of which Mr Crowe is a longtime participant in addition to his acting career) its detrimental when singing a semi-operatic musical theater score. While his songs don’t soar, I imagine 99 percent of movie goers aren’t going to care, as long as there are lots of closeups of his eyes. One of the movie reviews I read called him a “singing fire hydrant”.

Anne Hathaway gives an Oscar-worthy performance as Fantine, and her “I Dreamed A Dream” will win her that statuette next month. Might as well mail it to her already.

Amanda Seyfried (Cosette) and Eddie Redmayne (Marius) both have too much vibrato in their voices, but their acting is genuine and in the case of Redmayne, at times exhilarating. “Empty Chairs at Empty Tables” is emotionally overwhelming. Samantha Barks fares better as Eponine, but then she gets the musicals best songs by far. Helena Bonham Carter and Sasha Baron Cohen play the Thenardiers for laughs, and the parts are what they are — they are out of place in the stage musical, and they look even more out of place in the movie. Aaron Tveit makes for an excellent Enjolras.  The ensemble is terrific — and if you look closely, you will find dozens of Broadway and West End musical theater up and comers, in particular the guys playing the student compatriots of Marius and Enjolras.

Director Tom Hooper’s approach to the film is to close down some of it into closeup, while opening up other scenes for wide panoramas of sweeping scope. Aside from one odd shot in which St Paul’s Cathedral is visible in “Paris” (the movie was filmed in London), the sets look appropriately Parisian in nature. Most of the movie is filmed using hand-held cameras — now the standard for most action movies, new for musicals to be sure. There are some extreme closeups, and there are dizzying angles and camera sweeps. Photographers refer to putting things in “thirds”…Hooper works, at times, in “fourths” – with Javert, in particular, often appearing in the 4th quarter of the screen with nothing in the first three quarters. Its off-putting, and unique. After awhile, you start to feel that you are part of the action, that you are there, that you are peeking at the action from behind a crate or a ledge above; and Hooper wants it that way.

Les Miserables has always had its debates among the performance set: it’s an operetta masquerading as a musical…it’s a musical with operatic overtones. Its overblown, its overlong, its perfect. It should come as no surprise that the same debate rages now that the movie has been released. Take a look at the Broadway forum “All That Chat” for plenty of vitriol and debate. Reviews have been all over the map.

In reality, I don’t think it matters. Chalk up Oscar nominations for Best Picture, Best Actor (Hugh Jackman), Best Actress (Anne Hathaway), Best Supporting Actor (Eddie Redmayne), and a slew of technical awards, from costumes to scenic design.

Home for the Holidays, Dionysus Theatre, Review

Looks like Steve DeBruyne and Matthew Tomich have found (at least temporarily) a home for Dionysus Theatre at the Hartland High School auditorium — and its in a small beautiful space with professional amenities that theater companies envy. Its also a short 25 minute drive north of Ann Arbor (half the distance to Croswell for those who head there regularly) and they can use your support.

In a house that holds several hundred, only a handful were in attendance last night for their delightful original musical HOME FOR THE HOLIDAYS — think “Bing Crosby Christmas Special” and its about all you need to know about the evening. Its a jolly Christmas-song filled entertaining two hours complete with surprise appearance by He Who Drives A Sleigh.

15 member cast and 5 piece orchestra weave an enchanting holiday spell as they tell their story interspersing on-stage and back-stage antics at a Christmas Eve holiday show. Familiar holiday tunes (some used very effectively here) abound, and there is plenty of great singing, dancing, and all-around fun. Look for a special appearance by “star” Liz Jaffe.

In a uniformly solid cast, Steve DeBruyne, Liz Jaffe, Marlene Inman-Reilly and Sarah Brown are particular standouts, but the entire cast is strong. Steve DeBruyne’s direction is fluid; Brian E. Buckner’s vocal arrangements and band are terrific; and Michelle Marzejon’s choreography fits the bill. There is nice setwork by Phil Harmer, and overall technical touches are very good — much more “ready for prime time” than another local professional theater when they launched a few seasons ago. Also look for one of those special appearances that I covet — Anne Bauman arrives on stage in Act II, sings one song, and calls it a night. My kind of featured role!

But, it appears that Livingston County doesn’t exactly know what to do with a new theater company — so there is lots of education that needs to be done in this community about theater attendance (and behavior inside the theater, which does not include talking, texting, and eating meals). This is a theater that deserves your support — and its only a short drive away from Ann Arbor, and a hop-and-a-skip from points north. Get off at 59, make your first left, and follow the signs to the new High School. But more importantly, help support this new theater company which promises great things. Their next production, the musical 9 to 5 will have better name recognition and hopefully draw from a larger base — but their current holiday offering is a family-friendly holiday treat that goes down easily. Take some time out during this last weekend of their performances and pack up your car and head to Hartland for HOME FOR THE HOLIDAYS.

For tickets, call (517) 672-6009 or buy them online at http://www.diotheatre.com — or just buy your tickets at the door.

https://www.facebook.com/events/471469936238067/

“How the Grinch Stole Christmas” musical tour (review)

Take a 10-minute book, turned into a 30 minute tv special, and expand it to a 90-minute intermissionless musical, and you have the plusses and the minuses of the holiday musical “How the Grinch Stole Christmas” which is currently playing multiple times a day at the Detroit Opera House on its holiday tour.

There isn’t much critical to say about this production — it looks swell and the costume and set design is colorful and works well. The cast members are covered in loads of makeup and hair design, so they are pretty much interchangeable. I have several friends in this cast, and (honestly) I couldn’t pick them out in the ensemble for quite some time. Though I guess that is what it is.

Stefan Karl is an excellent Grinch, and he is clearly having a ball playing his part. He’s surrounded by an energetic cast, singing unremarkable songs, only the original animated tv version songs stand out (and “Your a Mean One Mr. Grinch” follows you home after the show — seriously, I listened to it about three times in the car on the way home and changed my ringtone to the tune)…and the Grinch stealing the presents sequence is brilliant.

The first third of the show is slow-going, but what follows is a holiday treat — well written, finely performed, and expertly designed, it’s like holiday cookies and milk. Sugary sweet, check. Lump in the throat, check. Grinch’s heart growing three sizes, check. Yours too. Feeling guilty in enjoying this tasty treat, check.

Just to make sure, though, there isn’t any mistaking this production with a typical Broadway show (even though this did run in NYC for several seasons)…it’s a holiday entertainment that is fun for the entire family. And based on this afternoon’s very full (and skewed toward toddlers) audience, families are turning out in droves.

Welcome, welcome Christmas Day…fun fluff, you’ll have a fun time.

 

Broadway-bound JEKYLL & HYDE revisal is excellent…(Tour review, Detroit)

There’s no way around it…you either love Jekyll & Hyde the musical or you hate it…and this production might just change a few minds for those who don’t. Completely restaged, reimagined, re-orchestrated and more in line with the original concept album than the 97 Broadway production, the revised Broadway bound Jekyll & Hyde is magnificent and gets just about everything right that the original did not.

tumblr_m84yqmn3kZ1qcfo4q
Constantine Maroulis is excellent as Jekyll/Hyde as is Deborah Cox as Lucy. Teal Wicks turns in an emotional and heartfelt Emma and Laird Mackintosh as Utterson is steadfast and steady. Round it out with a fine supporting cast that never seems superfluous and never meanders across the stage without purpose as in the past production and you have a Broadway-ready cast and crew. All 20 cast members here are strong. Maroulis in particular is superb in the duel role of Jekyll and Hyde and he is in fine voice. Before the American Idol folks chime in, let me just remind people that before he was on that contest, he was a graduate of the Boston Conservatory and had done work at the Williamstown Theater Festival. He sings the part better than any performer I have heard in this part professionally.

Moodily atmospheric, Tobin Ost’s sets and costumes are stunning–and the stage far less cluttered and claustrophobic than the original…it works perfectly, complemented by Daniel Brodie’s excellent projections and Jeff Croiter’s rock-concert type lighting. The set and projections are so intertwined I’m not sure who to praise more, Tobin or Daniel, so I will praise them both.

Particularly effective here are the Fascade number (previously ensemble milling around in clumps) where, instead, maids and butlers dress the performers who play the Hospital Board of Governors. Another problematic number “Confrontation” which originally saw Jekyll turning his body side to side while singing “duet” with Hyde, here instead sings with a projection of Hyde, and it is magnificent projection design. Maroulis does very good vocal work here.

The one weakness at the Fisher is the sound design, which needs tweaking once it reaches the Richard Rodgers Theater, where it will no-doubt sound better than in the airplane-hanger-sized barn that is the Fisher Theater in Detroit.

This is a brand new show unlike the original and far superior to it. Who knew?  Clearly Frank Wildhorn did, as this reworked production is masterful. Credit director/choreographer Jeff Calhoun who manages it all at lightning pace without ever once missing a beat, while also not giving short-shrift to the quiet moments and emotion. Its very good work, and will surely be recognized at Tony time (as will, no doubt Tobin Ost’s set and Maroulis’s Jekyll/Hyde).  It comes in at 2:25 including intermission, and that is just right for this show. The great-looking scenery motion adds to the thrill — there are big pieces moving around here, and they flip and spin and rotate and revolve and form and reform like a gigantic erector set. No test-tubes and flickering candles in this lab, but an eerie, gothic, moody sensibility pervades everything.

Instant standing ovation at the end — expected of course, since this show has always thrilled audiences more than critics. I’ve been fortunate to direct this musical twice now…a few years from now, I am looking forward to directing this revised version somewhere, someday. Its superb. New Yorkers, feel free to purchase your tickets now — its coming in as a big fat certified hit.

I suppose I could have made this a much shorter review by just simply writing “I loved this production, go see it.”
Bravo.

Broadway Fall 2012 – Annie, Drood, Chaplin (reviews)

Musical Theater is in full swing on Broadway this fall, with some new material, and some revivals — and the good news is, whatever you choose, you’ll be in for a treat. Seen the weekend of November 16 – 18, this trip included revivals of Annie and The Mystery of Edwin Drood, and the new musical Chaplin.

Lets start with the must-see performance of the season: Rob McClure as Charlie Chaplin in CHAPLIN. His physicality is amazing — from balancing on a tightwire, to pratfalls and tap dance, this is a star-making turn for a relatively unknown actor who has been working for years. Not only does his physical performance rate attention, but so does his ability to age from young adulthood to old age over the course of a couple of hours at the Ethel Barrymore Theatre. He commands your attention each moment he is on the stage (which is pretty much the entire 2 hour-15 minutes performance – the show runs 2:30 with intermission). Not surprisingly, the Equity Fights Aids Broadway Cares auction at the end of the show raised 7000.oo for his autographed derby hat.

Great performances are also turned in by Wayne Alan Wilcox as his brother Sydney; Jenn Colella as Hedda Hopper, and at my performance Emilee Dupre as Chaplin’s mother, Hannah. Apparently Christiane Noll (the usual Hannah) has a contract which allows her frequent missed performances in order to perform her concerts across the country. Not to worry, Emilee is a terrific understudy. In general, the entire ensemble is solid.

The rest of the show doesn’t fare as well — stunning greyscale set design by Beowulf Boritt and costumes by Amy Clark and Martin Pakledinaz lit in shades of white and shadow by Ken Billington can’t hide the horrendous script by Christopher Curtis and Thomas Meehan, and bland music by Mr Curtis. Warren Carlyle’s busy direction and choreography can’t hide the gaping holes in script, and the banality of what is there. Chaplin is a fascinating character to be sure — but there’s little to learn in this musical between good-guy-come-millionaire in Act I, and possible communist spy in Act II. When you start rooting for Hedda Hopper to make it “all fall down” (a lyric repeated ad-nauseum throughout the show) its a sure sign that the audience is looking for someone, anyone, to spark some life into the script.

But oh, what a production. There is a reason this almost universally panned-by-critics musical is packing them in from night to night — and that is the cast that is solid from top to bottom, the excellent technical work,  and Rob McClure’s simply stunning performance. Its really an evening not to be missed, even though you might leave the theater wondering what this Chaplin guy was all about anyway.

Across the street on Broadway, they’re packing them in at the revival of ANNIE at the Palace Theatre, and its a dazzling new production. Directed by James Lapine and choreographed by Andy Blankenbuehler, the show quickly moves from orphanage to mansion and back again with lots of fun along the way. David Lorins forced-perspective sets look wonderful, and some aspects downright magical — take for instance the rooms of the Warbucks mansion, which flip like pages of a storybook as Annie is led from room to room upon her arrival.

We are a bit jaded here in the Midwest when it comes to ANNIE — its a show that has been done by every regional, community, high school, and junior high school in America — but its not that true in NYC, where the show made a revival appearance in the late 90’s and now again in this fresh new version. If you’ve seen Annie (and who hasn’t) you deserve to see it done right — with a professional cast and set design. Watching a professional production makes you realize why the show is such a challenge no matter who performs it; not only do you need a strong lead cast, but you also need an excellent across-the-board ensemble to make it all work. While the kids bring in the houses, the show is really about the adults.

And what a cast this production sports! Katie Finneran is a dynamo as Miss Hannigan, dripping with little girls (all of them very good).  Anthony Warlow makes for a highly likable Warbucks and he is a great actor, singer, and dancer. Brynn O’Malley performs a very strong Grace Farrell and gets to wear Susan Hilferty’s best clothing in the show (Go Blue, Brynn!) but also brings warmth and heart to her role; Clarke Thorell and J. Elaine Marcos (as Rooster and Lili) are hilarious and restrained — Clarke’s Canadian accent in the second act made me laugh out loud. Lilla Crawford, the usual Annie, was out for the evening, and her understudy, Taylor Richardson was superb! You can’t go wrong with any of the kids, and Taylor ranks among the best of the professional Annies (who now number legion).

Go see the show — but remember, if your young ones cant sit still for 2 hours 30 minutes, then they do not belong inside the theater. The young ones in the theater come to life when the kids are onstage (which is for about 20 minutes of the entire show) and tune out for the rest. The family sitting next to me in the middle of the orchestra all required straight jackets and muzzles – kids and parents.

Finally, the revival of Rupert Holmes’s THE MYSTERY OF EDWIN DROOD is getting rave reviews at Studio 54 under the production of Roundabout Theatre Company. This has always been one of my favorite musicals, and your enjoyment will be greatly enhanced if you don’t mind audience participation, clapping and singing along, shouting “Drood” every time the name of the show is announced, and taking great personal responsibility to vote for the detective and the murder in Act II.

It looks great at the small Studio 54 theater, and Anna Louizos wraps it all in a Music Hall shell. The split orchestra in the side booths is under the direction of Paul Gemingani and they sound great. William Ivy Long creates the costumes, and they are colorful and delicious. Warren Carlyle choreographs with energy, and Scott Ellis directs with a sure hand and skill at controlling organized chaos on stage.

And what a cast! Stephanie J. Block; Will Chase; Gregg Edelman; Chita Rivera; Jim Norton; Andy Karl; Jessie Mueller; Betsy Wolfe; Nicholas Barasch; Peter Benson; Robert Creighton — its a virtual who’s who of current Broadway in multiple generations of performers. Jessie Mueller turns in a particularly wonderful performance as Helena Landless (of the vague and somewhat geographically untraceable accent)…as does Will Chase as John Jasper. But the entire cast shines, and everyone has their featured moment and it all feels just right.

While there are alternate endings based on audience vote, you can virtually be assured that everyone sees the same pairings from show to show — comparing who played what with friends who have seen the show over the past week all indicated the exact same actors were voted upon to take up the duties from show to show. Still, it feels fresh and spontaneous, as if the performers really did just learn of their vote. A particularly nice touch is slate-boards that hang over the exit, on which the audience can see that evening’s exact tally of how many votes each suspect got in the audience vote. (by the way, take a close look at those tallies and you will see why the same folks get voted on show after show — the tallies are not even close).

You can’t go wrong with any of these current shows. New musicals also running (and previously reviewed in this blog) are A CHRISTMAS STORY and ELF. And the only other new musical entry on Broadway, Kathy Lee Gifford’s SCANDALOUS, has recently opened to horrendous reviews at the Neil Simon Theatre.